He did it well. There are interesting character arcs, odd bits of backstory, and the not-really-told (in the books, that is) tale of The Necromancer of Dol Goldur is woven into the film. The scenery is still pretty. The action sequences are fine -- I loved the running battle through the Goblin Deeps under the Misty Mountains - and all your favourites are back. There's Old Bilbo (Ian Holm), a little Frodo, some Saruman (hooray!), some Elrond, some Galadriel, and a cheerfully eccentric Sylvester McCoy doing Radagast the Brown -- a wizard who rates about a line and a half in all of Tolkien's books put together.
I enjoyed myself. That was nice. And of course, I have our Kiwi brethren to thank for that, right?
And yet... and yet...
This is a picture of a Cadbury's Mighty Perky Nana bar.
And here is a photo of a mighty perky model, holding a Mighty Perky Nana Bar. Through the magic of Blogtography, you can even see what our model is thinking! (Hell of a camera, that Canon.)
And what, pray tell, is a Mighty Perky Nana Bar? Well... there are ingredients. Yes. They are as follows: Milk Chocolate, wheat, glucose syrup, sugar, vegetable fat, milk solids (milk solids? Do they mean cheese?) cocoa mass, cocoa butter, dried egg white (oooh.) maltodextrin, cocoa powder (how is that not covered under "cocoa mass"?) food acid, emulsifiers, soya, lecithin, flavours, gelatine, colours... actually, that's not much help, is it? Maybe we can get a better idea by watching our model.
Chewy? Is that the 'milk solids'? Or is it the dried egg white? This is not a promising start.
She has a verdict! Yes, faithful readers -- a Mighty Perky Nana Bar tastes yellow!
But perhaps that's not a good thing?
Our model is faced by an age-old dilemma...
I'm pretty sure those are not tears of joy. (I can promise you that our formerly perky model isn't even named Joy, so even that dodge is out.)
And that's where our saga ends. I didn't see any point in trying to photograph the gruesome aftermath. I will add only this:
(Did that work? If not, you can find the URL right here...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y-pksPxX0cw )
So, there you have it. On the one hand, Peter Jackson, Lord of the Rings, and now The Hobbit. And on the other, Cadbury's Mighty Perky Nana Bar.
YOU BE THE JUDGE!